Title card reading "Robert Nikic on 5 Common Lawsuits Small Businesses Face", by Robert Nikic
Business Law & Policy

Robert Nikic on 5 Common Lawsuits Small Businesses Face

·· 9 min read

In short: Most lawsuits against small businesses fall into five familiar types: contract and payment disputes, employment claims, trademark and IP claims, accessibility claims and customer injury or product claims. Nearly all of them are cheaper to prevent than to fight in court. This guide explains each one, the warning signs and a prevention checklist, plus what to do in the first 72 hours if you're ever sued.

I've started a lot of businesses, and the legal side was rarely what I wanted to think about. But every founder learns the same lesson eventually: the paperwork you skip at the start is the lawsuit you face later. You don't need to be a lawyer. You need a few habits.

What do courts actually see?

Not what you see on TV. The National Center for State Courts' landmark study of civil cases found that nearly two-thirds (64%) of the caseload was contract cases, mostly debt collection, landlord-tenant and foreclosure matters. It also found that most civil cases involve straightforward facts and relatively small amounts of money (National Center for State Courts).

More recent data points the same way. Early 2025 figures from the NCSC's Court Statistics Project show civil growth concentrated in contract disputes, small claims and debt collection (National Center for State Courts).

For a small business, that's useful. The most common legal fights are about money and promises, and those are the easiest to prevent.

Lawsuit #1: Contract and payment disputes

What it looks like: a client says you didn't deliver what you promised, you say they didn't pay what they owe, or a supplier says you broke an agreement.

Why it happens: the deal was never written down clearly. "We'll handle the marketing" means something different to each side.

Warning signs
- Scope changes agreed by phone, never confirmed in writing
- Invoices paid later and later
- "We'll sort out the details later"

Prevention checklist
- [ ] Every deal has written terms: deliverable, price, due date and what "done" means
- [ ] Scope changes get confirmed by email before work starts
- [ ] Invoices go out the day work is done
- [ ] Payment terms, late fees and the dispute process are stated up front
- [ ] You keep delivery proof: tracking, photos, sign-off emails

Most of these cases settle or end in small claims. I've written a full escalation playbook in Getting Paid Without a Lawsuit or Court.

Lawsuit #2: Employment claims

What it looks like: a worker says they were owed overtime, were wrongly treated as a contractor, or were fired or not hired for a discriminatory reason.

Why it happens: small businesses grow fast and informally. The first hires are often friends, contractors or part-timers with no written policy at all.

The contractor trap. The Department of Labor says employers are responsible for deciding whether a worker is an employee, and that misclassifying an employee as an independent contractor can deny them minimum wage and overtime protections (U.S. Department of Labor). It also notes that receiving a 1099 or signing a contractor agreement doesn't by itself make someone an independent contractor. The federal rules on this question have changed more than once, and a new proposal was announced in February 2026, so check the current rule before you classify anyone.

Discrimination laws. Federal anti-discrimination law applies at different employer sizes. For example, Title VII generally covers employers with 15 or more employees. The EEOC runs a dedicated small business resource center explaining which laws apply to you (EEOC). State and local laws often apply to smaller employers too.

Warning signs
- "Contractors" who work set hours, use your tools and only work for you
- No written time records
- Hiring or firing decisions made without a documented reason

Prevention checklist
- [ ] Get advice before classifying anyone as a contractor
- [ ] Keep accurate time and pay records
- [ ] Write down basic policies: pay, hours, time off, conduct
- [ ] Document the job-related reason for hiring, discipline and firing decisions
- [ ] Know which federal and state laws apply at your headcount

Lawsuit #3: Trademark and IP claims

What it looks like: a brand says you used its name, logo or photos without permission, or sold its products without authorization.

Why it happens: sellers assume that because a product is available, they're allowed to sell it with the brand's name and images.

▶ Watch: Watch: Robert Nikic on trademark claims against sellers

Not everyone can sell every product. Many brand-name products are "gated" on marketplaces, which means you have to upload proof you're authorized to sell them. Some sellers go looking for products that slip through without that check. A few months later, the account gets suspended, because what's actually happening is trademark infringement. Big companies protect their IP.

The USPTO explains that a trademark identifies the source of goods and that owners can take action against confusing uses (USPTO).

Prevention checklist
- [ ] Sell brand-name products only with authorization or from authorized distributors, and keep the paperwork
- [ ] Never use a brand's logo, photos or copy without permission
- [ ] Search before you name your own brand, and consider registering it
- [ ] Respond quickly and professionally to any IP notice

For the full breakdown, see Robert Nikic on Trademark Lawsuits: Why Sellers Get Sued.

Lawsuit #4: Accessibility claims (ADA)

What it looks like: a customer with a disability says they couldn't access your store, facility or website.

Why it happens: most small businesses never think about accessibility until someone raises it.

Title III of the Americans with Disabilities Act applies to businesses open to the public, and the Department of Justice explains that this includes making sure people with disabilities can access the goods and services you offer, including online (ADA.gov). The DOJ points to existing standards like the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines as helpful guidance. For physical locations, the ADA also requires removing architectural barriers when it's readily achievable to do so (ADA.gov).

Prevention checklist
- [ ] Add alt text to images and captions to videos on your website
- [ ] Make sure text has strong color contrast and forms work with a keyboard
- [ ] Run an accessibility check on your main pages
- [ ] Give people an easy way to request help, like a phone number or email
- [ ] For physical locations, review entrances, parking and restrooms

Lawsuit #5: Customer injury and product claims

What it looks like: a product causes harm, or someone gets hurt at your location.

Why it happens: quality wasn't checked, warnings were missing, or the premises weren't maintained.

The Consumer Product Safety Commission has a business guidance center that explains safety requirements, testing and reporting for consumer products (CPSC). If you sell physical products, especially for children, it's worth reading before you place your first order.

Prevention checklist
- [ ] Buy from reputable suppliers and ask for safety documentation
- [ ] Test products yourself before selling them
- [ ] Include clear instructions and warnings
- [ ] Keep records of where each batch came from
- [ ] Carry general liability insurance, plus product liability if you sell goods

The SBA's guide to business insurance explains the main types of coverage small businesses use (SBA).

What does a lawsuit actually cost a small business?

More than the check you might write at the end. The real costs usually include:

  • Legal fees, even for a case you win
  • Your time, pulled away from customers and sales
  • Insurance deductibles and possibly higher premiums later
  • Settlement or judgment amounts, if you lose or decide to settle
  • Stress and distraction, which are hard to price but very real

The good news is that most civil cases never reach a full trial. The National Center for State Courts found that civil cases are very rarely decided on the merits. Most are resolved by default judgment or dismissal (National Center for State Courts). That cuts both ways. If you ignore a case, a default judgment can be entered against you. If you respond and stay organized, many disputes end long before a courtroom.

Once a year, block 30 minutes and answer these questions honestly:

  1. Do I have a standard agreement that I actually use for every customer and supplier?
  2. Are my workers classified correctly, and do I have time and pay records?
  3. Do I have written authorization for every brand I sell or advertise?
  4. Has my website had an accessibility check in the last year?
  5. Does my insurance match what I do now, not what I did when I started?
  6. Do I know which lawyer I'd call tomorrow if I needed one?
  7. Could I find any contract, invoice or delivery record in under five minutes?

Any "no" is your to-do list for the next month. None of these items is expensive. All of them are cheaper than a lawsuit.

Your lawsuit risk matrix

Score your business 1 (low) to 3 (high) on how exposed you are to each type.

Lawsuit type Most exposed if you... Your score (1–3) First fix
Contract and payment Work without written terms Standard agreement template
Employment Have workers without written policies or records Classification review, time records
Trademark and IP Sell or market other brands Authorization file
Accessibility Have a website or public location Accessibility check
Injury and product Sell physical goods or host customers Insurance and supplier documents

Anything you score 3 on is this month's priority.

What should you do in the first 72 hours if you're sued?

  1. Don't ignore it. Missing a deadline can lead to a default judgment against you. Court papers usually tell you how long you have to respond, and in Florida, for example, a defendant generally has 20 days to respond to a civil complaint after being served. In small claims, you must show up at the pretrial conference. Deadlines vary by state, so confirm yours with a lawyer.
  2. Write down the key dates from the papers.
  3. Call a lawyer. Even a one-hour consultation helps.
  4. Notify your insurer. Many policies require prompt notice.
  5. Gather everything: contracts, emails, invoices, photos and records.
  6. Stop talking about it publicly. Don't post about the case or contact the other side in anger.
  7. Consider settlement or mediation. Many cases end there.

What should every small business have before a lawsuit happens?

  • A standard agreement template you use every time
  • General liability insurance, plus product coverage if you sell goods
  • A lawyer you've already spoken to once
  • A habit of putting things in writing
  • Organized records you can find in minutes

▸ What I'd change
Legal costs are one of the quiet reasons small businesses stay small. A dispute that's a rounding error for a large company can wipe out a year's profit for a small one. In my advisory work on SDG 8 & 9, I push for simpler rules and cheaper ways to resolve small disputes, like online mediation, plain-language standard contracts and small claims processes that work without a lawyer. That supports SDG target 8.3 on helping small businesses grow (UN). That's my view as an advisor, not an official position of any UN body.

FAQ: common small business lawsuits

What is the most common lawsuit against small businesses?
Contract and payment disputes. State court data shows contract cases make up the largest share of civil cases.

How can a small business avoid being sued?
Put deals in writing, keep good records, classify workers correctly, use only authorized brand materials, check accessibility and carry the right insurance.

Can a small business be sued over its website?
Yes. Businesses open to the public can face ADA accessibility claims, and websites can also raise trademark and copyright issues.

What should I do if my business gets sued?
Don't ignore it. Note the deadlines, talk to a lawyer, notify your insurer and gather your records.

Does insurance cover lawsuits?
Some policies cover certain claims and legal defense costs. Check what your general liability, product and employment practices coverage include.

Most lawsuits start with something that was never written down.

What is Robert Nikic's view on small-business lawsuits?

Robert Nikic's view is that most small-business lawsuits are preventable with written terms, good records, correct worker classification, authorized brand use and the right insurance, and that cheaper ways to resolve small disputes would help small firms most.

General information, not legal advice.

Related reading: Robert Nikic on Trademark Lawsuits: Why Sellers Get Sued · Robert Nikic on Getting Paid Without a Lawsuit or Court · Robert Nikic on Small Claims Court for Unpaid Invoices

Share
Robert Nikic
Robert Nikic

Entrepreneur, TEDx speaker and Advisory Council Chair at Reseated Councils (United Nations SDG 8 & 9). The company he founded and led from 2011 to 2026 was a two-time Inc. 5000 honoree, climbing to #35 nationally. Today his work centers on United Nations SDG 8 & 9.